 |
 |
This article does not cite any references or sources. Please help improve this article by adding citations to reliable sources. Unverifiable material may be challenged and removed. (April 2008) |
The letter of the law versus the spirit of the law is an idiomatic antithesis. When one obeys the letter of the law but not the spirit, he is obeying the literal interpretation of the words (the 'letter') of the law, but not the intent of those who wrote the law. Conversely, when one obeys the spirit of the law but not the letter, he is doing what the authors of the law intended, though not adhering to the literal wording.
'Law' originally referred to legislative statute, but in the idiom may refer to any kind of rule. Intentionally following the letter of the law but not the spirit may be accomplished through exploiting technicalities, loopholes, and ambiguous language. Following the letter of the law but not the spirit is also a tactic used against an oppressive government.
Contents |
Pro and con
Following the spirit of the law but not the letter is generally viewed more favorably than following the letter but not the spirit. In a court of law, judges usually review the intent of the players involved.
Authoritarians tend to view 'following the spirit' negatively as disobeying the law. The reason is that the actual intent of the law may be ambiguous, and allowing anyone to follow his own interpretation of the law may result in anarchy.
Shakespeare
William Shakespeare wrote numerous plays dealing with the letter v. spirit debate, almost always coming down on the side of 'spirit', often forcing villains (who always sided with the letter-based arguments) to have their letter-based interpretations turned against them. For example, see The Merchant of Venice and Measure for Measure.
However, in many of Shakespeare's history plays, the heroes often base their actions on letter-based arguments. See Henry V (Henry's basis for invading France), Richard II (the arguments for deposing Richard) or Richard III (Henry VII's argument for fighting Richard).
U.S. Constitutional Law
Interpretations of the U.S. Constitution have historically divided on the 'Letter v. Spirit' debate. For example, at the founding, the Federalist Party argued for a looser interpretation of the Constitution, granting Congress broad powers in keeping with the spirit of the broader purpose of some founders (notably including the Federalist founders' purposes). The Federalists would have represented the 'spirit' aspect. In contrast, the Democratic-Republicans, who favored a limited federal government, argued for the strict interpretation of the Constitution, arguing that the federal government was granted only those powers enumerated in the Constitution, and nothing not explicitly stated; they represented the 'letter' interpretation.
Modern Constitutional interpretation also divides on these lines. Currently, 'liberal' or 'progressive' scholars advocate a 'spirit'-esque interpretative strategy, although one grounded in a spirit that reflects broad powers. 'Originalist' or 'Textualists' advocate a more 'letter'-based approach, arguing that the Amendment process of the Constitution necessarily forecloses broader interpretations that can be accomplished simply by passing an amendment.
Pharisees
- See also: Law in Christianity
In the New Testament, Pharisees are seen as people who place the letter of the law above the spirit (Mark 2:3–28, 3:1–6). Thus, 'Pharisee' has entered the language as a pejorative for one who does so; the Oxford English Dictionary defines Pharisee with one of the meanings as A person of the spirit or character commonly attributed to the Pharisees in the New Testament; a legalist or formalist.
The phrases 'the letter of the law' and 'the spirit of the law' themselves are not found in the Bible. Some might connect 2 Corinthians 3:6 with such an idea, but that passage talks about 'the letter' versus 'the Spirit', where 'the letter' refers to the Old Covenant and its rules, while 'the Spirit' refers to the Holy Spirit (and the New Covenant).
Gaming the system
Gaming the system, also called 'rules lawyering', is related to following the letter but not the spirit of the law. It is used negatively to describe the act of manipulating the rules to achieve a personal advantage. It may also mean acting in an antisocial, irritating manner while technically staying within the bounds of the rules.
References
See also
- The Spirit of the Laws, the 1748 political theory treatise by Montesquieu
- Rules lawyer
- Positive law & Natural law
- Malicious compliance & Work-to-rule
- Expounding of the Law
Other uses
- The Letter of the Law, 1936 short story by Wodehouse
- Takeru: Letter of the Law, 1996 interactive comic
Article is licensed under GNU Free Documentation License.
It uses material from Wikipedia.org Original article is here.
Letter_of_the_law - Live Search NotizieRisultati della ricerca
Yahoo! News Search Results for Letter_of_the_law
Miniature golf course wins major battle (FOX 13 Tampa Bay)The owners of a miniature golf course in New Port Richey are celebrating a legal victory that some of the country's biggest companies failed to win. The owners of Monster Mini Golf were facing a long legal battle with a California high-tech firm that accused them of illegally using the word "monster.
A zest for lemons (San Francisco Chronicle)Although I lead a basically law-abiding life, there is one little area in which I indulge in the teeniest bit of larceny: lemons. If it is citrus season, chances are my pockets are bulging with as many lemons as I can grab when I pass a tempting tree....
Police adjust to new pot law (The Acton Beacon) With possession of small amounts of marijuana no longer a criminal offense in Massachusetts, local police are adapting to the new law but say that several loopholes could hamper their ability to enforce it.
Anti-tolls veteran in prince plea (BBC News)Campaigner Robbie the Pict turns to Prince Charles for help after an unsuccessful approach to the Queen.
How to kill a company (rediff.com)Raising deposits from the public and issuing shares with differential voting rights allow firms to raise vital funds, yet the new Companies Bill 2008 prohibits them, says K S Mehta.
Two get jail time in assault on elderly man (The Frederick News-Post)Emory Eugene Rice was gratified Wednesday to hear that two men accused of attacking and robbing him in July would spend 18 months behind bars
Retailer takes on new role (Asheboro Courier-Tribune)ASHEBORO — Jimmy Riddle is familiar to Asheboro shoppers. For decades, he sold men’s and women’s apparel in a family business called Riddles Inc. Riddle can still measure and mark a suit for alterations with the best of them. Peg a coat size or sleeve length by eying a customer.
Mangels Industrial's Bob Mangels: 'Family Investors Are Different Than Family Businesses' (Knowledge at Wharton)Founded in 1928, Mangels Industrial is among Brazil's leading manufacturers. Its products range from cold rolled steel to gas cylinders. In addition, the company is Latin America's largest maker of aluminum wheels for the auto industry. How are manufacturers such as Mangels Industrial coping with the global recession? In an interview with Knowledge@Wharton, Bob Mangels, company CEO and grandson ...
Studying Social Sciences (Deccan Herald)Iasked a second year BA student who has been studying sociology and psychology for the past three years, whether she feels that her subjects are going to be useful to her in future. She answered pensively, “I do like the subjects, but you cannot change society by studying sociology.”
Waymart to pursue junk vehicles (The Wayne Independent) Got a junk car or maybe a junk yard on your property in Waymart Borough? That will change if borough council passes an ordinance next month that cracks down on abandoned vehicles.
Live Search: Letter_of_the_lawRisultati della ricerca
The Letter of the Law Home PageThe Letter of the Law Home Page NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS® This information is intended for NAR members who are registered as users at REALTOR.org.
Letter of the Law Home PageLetter of the Law (LOTL) is a student-produced publication funded by the Student Bar Association (SBA) of Northwestern School of Law of Lewis ...
Letter Of the Law
Pharisees - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia ... pharisaical", etc.) has changed in meaning and has come into semi-common usage in English to describe a hypocritical and arrogant person who places the letter of the law above its ...
letter of the law - Idioms - by the Free Dictionary, Thesaurus and ... the letter of the law (formal) the exact words of a law and not its more important general meaning. There is always the danger that a judge may follow the letter of the law rather ...
Letter of the Law by Alan Edward Nourse - Project GutenbergDownload the free eBook: Letter of the Law by Alan Edward Nourse ... Did you know that you can help us produce ebooks by proof-reading just one page a day?
Letter of the Law legal definition of Letter of the Law. Letter of the ... The strict and exact force of the language used in a statute, as distinguished from the spirit, general purpose, and policy of the statute.
College Students VoteRegistering before Election Day is the best way to ensure that you will have a quick and hassle-free experience voting at the polls on Election Day.
Continuity Insights - The Letter of the Law: Data Breach Notification ... Issue Archive: November/December 2008 The Letter of the Law: Data Breach Notification Statutes Expose Gap in Incident Response Plans Author: Thomas E.
Shred to the letter of the law... safely and securely.With Amtrak there are no tolls, traffic or weather issues to deal with. Just big, comfortable seats and miles of breathtaking views and spend real quality time with family and ...
